From the available information I do not feel it was fearmongering.
Of course I might have been wrong on my assessment of the risk.
I also did not want to badword your great work - I just felt you did go into quite a risk and should warn about this. I admit the discussion went a bit out of hand.
As to Wipeout rewrite I was not aware until you told me it was a similar situation. But probably the thing is that in this case the ID Holders really don't care for it any longer (still myselves I would not touch it, but that's because I do porting of commercial titles myselves).
I found it BTW great you shared your fixes with smarkusg, even though this is probably "more stuff not allowed"
And I sincerely hope that nothing bad will happen due to the MorphOS version release.
I personally (!) think the way smarkusg handles it is fine though - he did a compile for himselves and did not release it to the public.
Personally I think they really should OpenSource this old title and get this whole discussions on many platforms done and over with. I am sure this issue does not only exist for AmigaOS and MorphOS...