@walkero
Quote:
I tested today the RC4 and I didn't have major issues
Great! - so it's worth a release candidate/Beta Version
. Thankyou for testing.
Quote:
Please take my comments as constructive ones. This doesn't mean that you have to do any of these or follow my proposals. I hope it helps.
I will, and your proposals will discussed and considered. This is acutally very important. I asked for comments, you deliverd on that, so thanks a lot for your input!
Which leads me to the discussion/answer:
The main issue seems to be a language one...usage of unexact terms.Let me explain:
Quote:
What is the difference between todo lists and lists?
There is no difference...e.g. you have a
shopping list and a list containing several tasks you want to accomplish in the next few days...lets call it e.g.
Task list.
You will see both lists on the
Home Tab inside the listview. Once you click on one of them, the list will be loaded, and stated in the window title...so this statement is "wrong":
Quote:
In the list tab, there is no mention of the todo list that is selected.
Therefore the checkboxes on this tab should not be read as "done/accomplished"...rather as "selected" for deletion. Maybe this will make it more obvious? :
rename
- "New todolist" into "New list"
- "Del todolist" into "Del list"
rearrange listview columns
- "list name" column first, then "Sel." column
Quote:
I do not understand how "On hold" list works, to be honest.
Basicaly this is an additional list, like any other list. Expect the name and an extra button (rather than putting it inside the listview)...
The
List Tab holds all the tasks you have to accomplish..so this is actually your "ToDo List" or "Task List". I guess it would be better to
rename "List" into "Tasks"
???
In our example, each shop you have to visit while accomplishing your shopping list, could be listed here....
The "New" Button just clears the two textgadgets and makes them ready for a new entrance/task. And yes this is sort of "unintituional"
rename "New" into "Clear"? Or maybe just a rubber icon next to the text gadgets?
????
The
Details Tab holds "Sub Tasks/Sub Items/Steps....". Therfor each task in the list tab can have its own (sub)list. E.g.: Lists the items to be shopped in the selected shop on tab "List".
Quote:
In the details tab, I do not understand what is the free text field under the buttons. Maybe you should add a frame with a title or a label above it. It doesn't change when I change an item from the list. Is it something that provides information about that list?
There you can add some notes for the selected item on the "List Tab"...e.g. Adress of the shop you selected. The selected item (e.g.shop" will be then stated inside the yellow label field.
Quote:
In the details tab, I am not sure what the "New" button is doing. Why is it there, since I can add items with the add button?
See above...
Quote:
There is no way from the details tab to add more information in any task, if needed, nor move it to other lists
Correct, this is only available for your tasks on the "List Tab" -> These changes/addition will then pop up on your "Detail Tab"
Maybe it is a good idea (???) to:
- move the free text field under the buttons (aka "notes") above the text fields and label it "notes"
- label the listview "steps"
What do you think?
Quote:
....Instead of having only two states of status, maybe you need more.
On hold = not working on currently...
Status = yes a third status like "WIP" is something I thought about, but will integrate in a future version...technically seen I have then to move away from checkboxes...
Quote:
Based on the screenshots above, it seems you target the app to work on mobiles as well. But perhaps the same UI is not working well on desktops, going back and forward with tabs.
Tabbed version is a good idea for mobile, however I thought about a different UI for the desktop version. But overall I think it's not to bad, as I want to keep the app in a small window on the desktop as well. MS ToDo does the same BTW, expect that the "Details Tab" pops up automatically...(not that I say MS is the UI standard
).
Quote:
For the readme.txt, do not assume that everyone has multiviewer installed. Better use the multiview as the default tool there.
100% readme.txt and documenation has to be polished before releas anyway.
Input on my ideas would be really appreciated, thankyou very much!
News feed
OS4 Feedback forum
OS4Depot Feedback forum
AmiCygnix forum
ABC shell forum
AmiKit forum
Cinnamon Writer forum
CodeBench forum
Digital Universe forum
Dopus 5 forum
E-UAE forum
Gnash forum
Ibrowse forum
JAmiga forum
Odyssey forum
OWB forum
Qt forum
SmartFileSystem forum
Timberwolf forum
TouchDevice forum
TuneNet forum
Unsatisfactory Software forum
Donate
